Question 1BeginnerCausation & remoteness
In a negligence claim, the ‘but for’ test is used to decide whether __________.
- Athe defendant owed the claimant a duty of care
- Bthe defendant’s breach actually caused the claimant’s loss
- Cthe claimant’s loss was of a reasonably foreseeable kind
- Dthe claimant freely accepted the risk of being injured
Show answer
Answer: B. the defendant’s breach actually caused the claimant’s loss
The ‘but for’ test asks whether the claimant would have suffered the loss but for the defendant’s breach; if the loss would have happened anyway, the breach did not cause it. Whether a duty is owed is decided by the Spandeck test, and whether the loss was of a foreseeable kind is the separate question of remoteness. Freely accepting a risk is the defence of volenti non fit injuria.
Question 2BeginnerDuty of care
Hedley Byrne v Heller (1964) is best known for establishing that __________.
- Aa manufacturer owes a duty of care to the ultimate consumer of its products
- Ba claimant who is partly to blame for his own loss recovers nothing at all
- Ca careless statement may make its maker liable for pure economic loss
- Dan occupier is liable for every injury that anyone suffers on his premises
Show answer
Answer: C. a careless statement may make its maker liable for pure economic loss
In Hedley Byrne, the House of Lords held that a person who gives advice or information, assuming responsibility for it and knowing it will be relied on, may owe a duty of care, so a careless statement can make him liable for purely financial loss; the bank there escaped only because of its disclaimer. This is the basis of a claim in negligent misstatement, for example against the other side’s salesperson. The manufacturer’s duty to consumers comes from Donoghue v Stevenson, and a claimant partly to blame has his damages reduced, not extinguished.
Question 3BeginnerBare & contractual licences
A buyer of standing timber is given permission to enter the seller’s land to cut the timber and take it away. This permission is __________.
- Aa licence coupled with an interest, irrevocable while the interest lasts
- Ba bare licence, which the landowner may revoke at any time he chooses
- Ca lease of the land, because the buyer has paid for the right to enter
- Da Temporary Occupation Licence, which must be for less than 10 years
Show answer
Answer: A. a licence coupled with an interest, irrevocable while the interest lasts
Where permission to enter land is attached to a proprietary interest, such as the right to take away timber or produce that has been bought, it is a licence coupled with an interest (or grant). It lasts as long as the interest it supports and cannot be revoked at will. A bare licence is a gratuitous permission, a lease needs exclusive possession for a term, and a TOL is a licence over State land.
Question 4BeginnerEquitable leases
Under the rule in Walsh v Lonsdale, where the parties have made an agreement for a lease that equity would specifically enforce, __________.
- Athe agreement has no effect until a formal lease is signed and registered
- Bthe occupier is only a licensee, whom the landlord may remove on notice
- Cthe agreement becomes a legal lease as soon as the first rent is paid
- Dequity treats the parties as if the lease had been granted on the agreed terms
Show answer
Answer: D. equity treats the parties as if the lease had been granted on the agreed terms
Because equity treats as done that which ought to be done, an agreement for a lease that would be specifically enforced takes effect in equity as if the lease had been granted on the same terms, so the tenant holds an equitable lease. Paying rent does not turn it into a legal lease, as the formalities for a legal lease must still be met, and an equitable lease should be protected by a caveat against later buyers.
Question 5BeginnerAssignment & subletting
Where a lease contains no covenant restricting assignment or subletting, the tenant __________.
- Amust obtain the landlord’s written consent before he assigns or sublets
- Bmay sublet part of the premises but may never assign the whole lease
- Cmay generally assign or sublet without needing the landlord’s consent
- Dmay assign only to a person the landlord approves as creditworthy
Show answer
Answer: C. may generally assign or sublet without needing the landlord’s consent
A lease is an interest in land, so unless the lease restricts it, the tenant is free to assign it or sublet without the landlord’s consent. That is why most leases contain an express covenant against assigning or subletting without consent. Even after an assignment, the original tenant remains liable on his covenants through privity of contract unless there is a novation.
Question 6BeginnerLease contents
In a lease, the habendum clause __________.
- Astates the estate or interest granted and the length of the term
- Breserves the rent to the landlord and states when it is to be paid
- Cdescribes the premises that are being let to the tenant
- Dsets out how the rent will be revised during the term
Show answer
Answer: A. states the estate or interest granted and the length of the term
The habendum clause (from “to have and to hold”) defines the interest granted to the tenant and its duration, for example “to hold for a term of 3 years from 1 March 2026”. The clause reserving the rent is the reddendum clause, the description of the premises is the parcels clause, and revising the rent is the job of a rent review clause.
Question 7IntermediateCausation & remoteness
On Tuesday, 6 October 2026, a contractor engaged by the MCST of a condominium in Bishan was replacing a lobby light fitting. He had set up his ladder across a busy walkway without any barrier, and a heavy screwdriver slipped from the top of it and struck Mr Ong Kah Beng, 70, a retired teacher who was visiting his grandson, on the shoulder. A healthy person would probably have suffered only bruising, but Mr Ong has a rare bone condition, and his shoulder fractured badly, needing surgery and months of physiotherapy. The contractor’s insurer admits that the contractor was careless but argues that it should pay only for bruising, as nobody could have foreseen such a serious injury. The condominium had passed its annual safety audit in July.
Which of the following BEST describes the extent of the contractor’s liability to Mr Ong?
- AHe is liable for bruising only, as a defendant answers only for the extent of injury that a reasonable person could have foreseen.
- BHe is not liable at all, as Mr Ong’s bone condition, not the falling screwdriver, was the real cause of the fracture he suffered.
- CHe is liable for half the loss, as the court apportions damages between the defendant’s carelessness and the claimant’s condition.
- DHe is liable for the whole fracture, as injury of that kind was foreseeable and a defendant must take his victim as he finds him.
Show answer
Answer: D. He is liable for the whole fracture, as injury of that kind was foreseeable and a defendant must take his victim as he finds him.
Under the ‘eggshell skull’ rule, once physical injury of the kind suffered was reasonably foreseeable, the defendant is liable for its full extent, even if a hidden weakness in the claimant made it far worse than expected. A heavy tool falling onto an open walkway was bound to cause some physical injury, so the contractor must pay for the fracture, the surgery and the physiotherapy. Mr Ong’s condition does not break the chain of causation, and it is not contributory negligence, which concerns a claimant’s own lack of care; the safety audit and the purpose of his visit are irrelevant.
Question 8IntermediateStandard of care
Ms Priya Nair, 33, works for a tenant on the 20th floor of an office building in Anson Road, which is owned and managed by Harbour Towers Pte Ltd. One morning, while she was waiting for a lift, a large glass panel fell from the lobby’s decorative ceiling and cut her arm badly. No contractor was working on the ceiling that day, and only the owner’s own maintenance team had access to it. Ms Priya has no idea why the panel fell. The owner’s manager tells her that she cannot sue unless she proves exactly what the maintenance team did wrong, and he adds that the building won an architecture award in 2019. Her employer has offered her paid medical leave.
Which of the following BEST describes Ms Priya’s position in a negligence claim against Harbour Towers?
- AShe will fail, as a claimant in negligence must always identify the precise careless act that caused her injury before any finding is made.
- BShe may rely on res ipsa loquitur, so the court may infer negligence unless the owner gives a satisfactory explanation of how the panel fell.
- CShe will succeed automatically, as a building owner is strictly liable for any accident on its premises, whether or not it was careless.
- DShe must sue her employer instead, as the tenant that employs her, and not the building owner, owes her a duty of care in the building.
Show answer
Answer: B. She may rely on res ipsa loquitur, so the court may infer negligence unless the owner gives a satisfactory explanation of how the panel fell.
Res ipsa loquitur (“the thing speaks for itself”) helps a claimant who cannot say exactly what went wrong: where the thing that caused the harm was under the defendant’s control and the accident is one that does not ordinarily happen if proper care is taken, the court may infer negligence, and the defendant must then give an explanation consistent with reasonable care. Ceiling panels do not usually fall without negligence, and only the owner’s team had access, so the manager is wrong. The inference is not strict liability, and the owner’s own duty to people in its lobby is not displaced by her employer. The architecture award and her medical leave are irrelevant.
Question 9IntermediateEssential characteristics of a lease
In January 2026, Mr Lim Teck Soon, 60, agreed in writing to let his Serangoon condominium unit to Mr Arif Hakim, 29, at $3,600 a month “until my daughter returns from her studies in London”. His daughter had just started a degree course and was unsure whether she would stay on for a master’s. Mr Arif has exclusive possession of the unit, has paid the rent on the 1st of every month, which Mr Lim has accepted, and has repainted the study. In October 2026, Mr Lim’s daughter decides to settle in London indefinitely, and Mr Lim asks his salesperson whether Mr Arif can be asked to leave. Mr Arif’s colleague has told him that he may stay for as long as the daughter remains abroad.
Which of the following BEST describes the nature of Mr Arif’s right to occupy the unit?
- ANo lease arises for that term, as its maximum duration was uncertain at the start, but he is likely to be a monthly periodic tenant.
- BHe holds a lease for as long as the daughter stays abroad, as the parties agreed on the event that would end it and he has paid rent.
- CHe is a yearly periodic tenant, as a letting that fails for uncertainty of term always becomes a tenancy from year to year.
- DHe is only a bare licensee, as an agreement that fails for uncertainty of term leaves the occupier with no protection whatsoever.
Show answer
Answer: A. No lease arises for that term, as its maximum duration was uncertain at the start, but he is likely to be a monthly periodic tenant.
A lease must be for a term whose commencement and maximum duration are certain when it takes effect, and a term lasting “until my daughter returns from her studies” could not be measured at the outset, so the agreement cannot create a lease for that term and the colleague is wrong. As Mr Arif has exclusive possession and pays, and Mr Lim accepts, a monthly rent, the law is likely to infer a monthly periodic tenancy, which either party may end by proper notice to quit, usually one month; the rent is paid monthly, so the periodic tenancy is monthly, not yearly. He is not a bare licensee, as he pays for exclusive possession, and repainting the study does not change the analysis.
Question 10IntermediateOutgoings, taxes & utilities
Mr Kenji Tanaka, 36, a Japanese engineer on an Employment Pass, signs a 3-year tenancy of a furnished condominium unit in Novena on Monday, 12 October 2026. The monthly rent of $5,150, which is in line with the market, is made up of $4,500 for the premises, $400 for the furniture and $250 for maintenance fees. The agreement does not say who pays the stamp duty. The landlord’s salesperson says duty is payable only on the $4,500 part, as the furniture and maintenance amounts are not ‘real rent’, while Mr Kenji’s colleague recalls paying duty at 0.8% on his own lease. Mr Kenji’s employer will reimburse him for the duty, and he plans to renew if the landlord agrees.
How much stamp duty is payable on Mr Kenji’s tenancy agreement?
- A$648
- B$1,483
- C$741
- D$247
Show answer
Answer: C. $741
For a lease of 4 years or less, lease duty is 0.4% of the total rent for the period of the lease, and IRAS includes charges such as those for furniture and maintenance in the rent. The total rent is $5,150 × 36 = $185,400, and 0.4% of that is $741.60, which is rounded down to the nearest dollar, giving $741. $648 leaves out the furniture and maintenance charges, $1,483 wrongly applies 0.8%, and $247 uses one year’s rent only; as the agreement is silent, Mr Kenji as tenant is liable for the duty, whatever his employer later reimburses.
Try a case study
In Section B of the exam, a set of questions follows one long scenario, worth 2 marks each. Read the case, then answer the questions below it.
Case study
The florist’s ‘licence’
Mdm Kwek Lay Hoon, 68, owns a two-storey shophouse in Joo Chiat and lives on the upper floor. On Monday, 2 February 2026, she signed a document headed “Licence Agreement” with Mr Benjamin Tay, 35, a florist, for the ground floor, for 2 years at $4,800 a month. Mr Benjamin holds the only keys to the shop, fits it out and runs it as he pleases, and Mdm Kwek has never gone in without his permission. The document states that it “creates a licence only and no tenancy”, forbids him to sublet any part of the shop without her written consent, and gives her a right of re-entry for any breach. Her nephew, a property investor, drafted it from an online template.
In June 2026, without asking, Mr Benjamin sublet the rear half of the shop to a nail salon. Mdm Kwek found out in early July and complained to her nephew, but she still accepted Mr Benjamin’s August and September rent in full, knowing of the subletting. In late September a bubble-tea chain offered her $6,500 a month for the ground floor. Her nephew now says she can simply revoke the licence on 7 days’ notice, and that if this fails she can forfeit for the unlawful subletting.
Question 11Case studyLicence vs lease
What is the legal nature of Mr Benjamin’s right to occupy the ground floor?
- AA licence, as the parties expressly agreed in writing that the document creates a licence only, and the court must give effect to that label.
- BA lease, as he has exclusive possession of identifiable premises for a certain term at a rent, whatever label the document uses.
- CA licence, as Mdm Kwek lives in the same building and so keeps overall control, which means that he cannot have exclusive possession.
- DA lease, but only because he has spent money fitting out the shop, which turned what began as a licence into a tenancy by estoppel.
Show answer
Answer: B. A lease, as he has exclusive possession of identifiable premises for a certain term at a rent, whatever label the document uses.
Whether an arrangement is a lease or a licence depends on its substance, not on what the parties call it. Mr Benjamin has exclusive possession of identifiable premises (he alone holds the keys, and she enters only with his permission) for a certain term of 2 years at a rent, which are the hallmarks of a lease, so the “licence” label does not decide the matter and the nephew cannot end it on 7 days’ notice. Living upstairs does not give Mdm Kwek control of the ground floor, and the fit-out is not what makes it a tenancy; the online template is irrelevant.
Question 12Case studyForfeiture & relief
Treating the arrangement as a lease, can Mdm Kwek now forfeit it for the unauthorised subletting to the nail salon?
- AYes, as unauthorised subletting is a serious breach, and she may re-enter at once without first serving any notice on Mr Benjamin.
- BYes, provided she first serves a notice under s 18 of the Conveyancing and Law of Property Act specifying the breach.
- CNo, as a landlord can never forfeit a lease for a breach other than non-payment of rent, however serious that breach may be.
- DNo, as by accepting rent that fell due after she knew of the subletting, she waived her right to forfeit for that breach.
Show answer
Answer: D. No, as by accepting rent that fell due after she knew of the subletting, she waived her right to forfeit for that breach.
A landlord who, knowing of a breach that gives a right to forfeit, accepts rent falling due after the breach waives the right to forfeit for that breach. Subletting without consent is a once-and-for-all breach, so by accepting the August and September rent with knowledge of it, Mdm Kwek lost the right to forfeit for it, and a s 18 notice cannot revive that right, although she may still claim damages for any loss the breach caused. Her rights for any later breach are unaffected, and the bubble-tea chain’s higher offer is irrelevant.
121 questions on Licences, Leases & Negligence in the app
Option to Pass has 1,850+ original questions across all 16 chapters at three levels, 80+ case studies and two full mock papers in the real exam format. Lesson 1A is free, with no sign-up.
More free questions for Paper 1